You may have heard, ICANN has approved a proposal to slacken the rules on the internets TLDs. Starting in early 2009, anyone with sufficent hardware, and a buisness plan, will be able to make their own TLD. I don’t like this for two main reasons.
Firstly, the internet is mean to be free. When companies start buying domain names like http://www.coca.cola, it will just have been turned in to one big advert. Which is not what we want. How long until we see things like http://www.mobilephones.buyhere? Or http://www.buycomputers.verycheap. The TLD is not meant to be user customizable. It is meant to give some basic information about the site. For example, .com is a company (although it has now turned more into a generic TLD, as seen in my URL). .net is a personal website. .org is a non profit organization, and then you get country specific TLDs, like .co.uk, .fr and .de. That is it’s main purpose, which brings me onto my second point.
As it is, the internet is structured. You know that when you read .com, you have come to the end of the address. When this proposal is implemented, URLS like http://buy.mobile.phones.here.very.cheap will be a vaild URL. We don’t want this! We want an address like http://subdomain.domain.com. At the moment, if you can’t remember the address of a website, you can safely try .com as the most likely TLD. If that doesn’t work, then .co.uk, .net and .org are safe ones to try. The internet will lose it’s structure. If there are no limits on the TLDs you can use, then it’s like being able to make up your own postcode. The internet will lose all structure.
This is my view, but if you disagree with me, please say so because I would be interested to know why.
